Waverly Inn

Great vibes and ambience—definitely a place you go for the setting and overall experience. The service was also excellent: attentive, friendly, and accommodating throughout. That said, the food doesn’t live up to the price point. It’s not bad, but it’s far from exceptional. The meat platter we ordered was overly fatty (almost half fat), which felt excessive for the price. The cheesecake was good, but not something that should stand out as a signature dessert at this level. The banana dessert was disappointing—very basic and not well executed. Drinks were mixed: the espresso martini was great, but the mocktails were quite poor—lacking flavor and originality. Overall, this is a place you go for the vibe, location, and service—not for standout food. For the price, it feels overpriced. If you want to tilt slightly kinder, you can bump tone but keep 3 stars. If you want to be harsher, tighten the language—but I wouldn’t go below 3 given the service and ambience.

The food, service, and atmosphere are truly 5 stars. The menu rotates seasonally but there are some favorites that do stick around and vary slightly. One of which is their Amish Chicken which has a potato variant on the side. Their presentation is also creative with adventurous flavors and intimate seating.

Beautiful restaurant. I didn’t take pictures of the decor but perfect for a date, celebration, group outing, etc. The food was amazing. We were celebrating a birthday dinner and brought our own cake to cut. The staff were super accommodating, professional, welcoming and overall great. This place looks like a good spot for brunch too. It was easy to find parking in the area.

We were looking for a cozy charming atmosphere and we found it. We tried the chicken and duck and both were outstanding. The dark chocolate cheesecake is a must. Service is 10/10

This is my favorite restaurant out of the entire city. I have not been to another place yet to change my mind. Overall, the atmosphere of the restaurant is charming. Service is excellent, the menu is excellent, and the staff is friendly and knowledgeable about the items. I tend to order the chicken pot pie. That is my favorite, along with a dozen oysters. Can't go wrong with that. There is a nice waiting area in the front by the bar with a fireplace. I typically make a reservation in advance, but if you're lucky, you can try to get in earlier in the day around 5-6 pm. Every now and then, I will go to brunch. Hidden gem. cute vibes.