Crazy Pizza NYC/East Hampton

Absolutely loved Crazy Pizza in East Hampton. The atmosphere is lively without feeling overdone, the service was warm and attentive, and the food was genuinely excellent. Importantly, this is not the place for people expecting traditional, heavy pizza. These are lighter, roughly 500-calorie pizzas with some of the thinnest crust I’ve ever had. Personally, I love that because it feels clean and doesn’t leave you feeling weighed down. But it’s worth knowing going in that this is not deep dish or a traditional NY-style thick crust. That said, if you like ultra-thin, crisp, flavorful pizza with great ingredients, it really delivers. It has that rare mix of being fun, polished, and still relaxed enough for a casual night out. Great spot for dinner with friends, date night, or bringing people from out of town who want something that feels very East Hampton but not stuffy. Definitely one of the better dining experiences I’ve had out east. Will absolutely be back.

Saw this place on TikTok, and it looked so fun and I needed to try it. It was easy to make reservations, the food was good, pizzas are very, very thin, and personalized. The only thing that was a little disappointing was the show, it literally lasted 30 seconds, wish it was longer. Also, the price for the amount of food was way more than it should be. So prepare to pay a lot. Would I go back, no really, but def checking it off my list!

Cannot begin to express how much fun Crazy Pizza was and how badly we need something festive like this in our town. What a ball we all had! Fun for all ages and delicious food. Wonderful service and stylish setting. We absolutely loved it and already have a reservation to go back.

We had SUCH a blast tonight at the bar with Will. The calamari, Caesar salad, pizza, wine, and vibe were excellent! Truly my favorite experience this summer and can’t wait to come back!