2nd time dining here since you opened last year. I also frequent your PB location. I took my sister here the other night to celebrate and commemorate, our dear departed mom’s birthday. Everything was perfect, and it was a special night for us. With good drinks, excellent service, and beautiful location. However, I ordered your specials for that night, which was the squid ink w/mussels and risotto. Disappointing, to say the least. Risotto was undercooked that it hurt my tooth (got a good set of teeth fyi😊) It was not enjoyable at all, i didn’t even eat a good portion of it , except for the 4 tiny mussels you included and some squid. $55 was not a joke anyway. I felt famished after consuming some drinks, i wasn’t satisfied at all. I told the server about it, twice. She didn’t do anything despite my complaints. Please please, do better next time. Swiftys is my favorite especially the PB location.
Pretty expensive for mediocre food. Brussel sprouts were great, but $27 for chips and guac....
Sticky toffee pudding was lovely.
Waitresses in $900 Zimmermann dresses and great people watching in the immaculately setting. You're paying for the privilege of sitting there and to be served well. Though I wouldn't say our server was at all experienced very sweet though.
Worth it for a one off. Probs won't be back.
The food was great and the atmosphere is stunning, but there were so many dropped moments in the service it was quizzical.
First off the waiter started abruptly after drink orders and asked curtly are we ready to order without welcoming us or talking about the specials. They took our plates halfway through appetizers not realizing we weren’t done with the fluke crudo so they had to get new plates and silverware . I asked for the drink menu when entrees came and then they never came back to get my drink order. They delivered the drinks and desserts to the wrong people.
None of this is catastrophic and we had a lovely time but the misses and lack of training and coordination at this price point are shocking.
On the food side, I highly recommend the pork tomahawk and the fluke crude as well as the sticky toffee pudding.
Terrible food, extremely expensive and called to say that if we were 10 min late we wouldn’t be allowed in. Meanwhile they will not answer there phone. Waitress robotic with no grace or care. They wanted to clear plates while 2 people out of 4 were still eating. We ordered the $89. Lamb chops and split them and they charged a $25 split fee!!!!! Small and not even good.
Swifty’s does a great job at the American classics . The flounder was light, airy and crispy on the outside and juicy and tender inside. The menu is very Hamptons classic ( lobster rolls, hamburger, cobb salad, etc..) and everything is done well . I think it’s best for brunch or lunch and I’ll try that next! loved it although prices are high but so is everything in the hamptons
