Photo by A. M. via Google Maps
An iconic brand on Martha's Vineyard, encompassing both a Bakery Cafe and a Tavern, known for its American comfort food, baked goods, and specialty coffees, with locations in Vineyard Haven (Tisbury).
The provided information does not identify Jack Mayhew as a chef. He is mentioned in historical contexts related to a restaurant owner and as a fish spotter.
Last updated: 7/7/2026, 5:09:42 AM
The Black Dog is a well-known brand on Martha's Vineyard, offering both a Bakery Cafe and a Tavern. The Bakery Cafe provides a warm, inviting, and dog-friendly atmosphere with a classic train car and outdoor seating. The Tavern boasts a waterfront view in Vineyard Haven, steps from the ferry, and is a year-round staple.
No Hungru reviews for The Black Dog yet. Taste it, share it, and claim the Restaurant Pioneer badge.
Help others discover what to order at The Black Dog
Your review helps others find the best dishes — and gets shared on Hungru.
Customer feedback is mixed. Many praise the delicious food, particularly the Buffalo chicken loaded tots and iced coffee, and appreciate the inviting atmosphere and friendly service at the Bakery Cafe. The gluten-free peanut butter cups and homemade bakery items are also highlighted positively. However, there are significant complaints regarding long wait times, incorrect orders, and a perceived lack of vegetarian and vegan options on the sandwich menu. Some reviews also mention issues with staff attentiveness.
The Black Dog brand is iconic on Martha's Vineyard, known for its distinctive logo and merchandise. The establishment in Tisbury (Vineyard Haven) includes both a Bakery Cafe and a Tavern, catering to different dining experiences.
The Black Dog Tavern and Bakery Cafe are open daily starting at 7:00 AM, making them ideal for breakfast and lunch. Given the waterfront location and outdoor seating, warmer months might be particularly enjoyable.
