Yard Sale Pizza is a Masterclass in the NY-London Hybrid
As someone who usually swears by a soft, blistered Neapolitan crust, Yard Sale does make me value the alt style, as they’ve mastered the New York-Italian style - think light, structural, and seriously crispy.
Our order...
The Margherita: This was a perfect baseline. The tomato sauce is the standout—fresh, sweet, and sharp in all the right places.
The New Porker. The Sicilian sausage is high-quality and well-balanced; it’s flavorful without being greasy.
The vibe. Watching the open kitchen is a joy. There’s a clear pride in the craft here that translates directly to the plate.
My advice is to dine in. These pizzas are thin and crisp, which means they lose heat quickly. While their takeaway is popular, you lose the best version of the crust in a cardboard box. Eat it fresh and hot and meters away from the hard working pizza oven.
Yard Sale offers a consistent, high-quality experience that earns its spot in the London pizza establishment. Highly recommended for a casual, top-tier meal.
Yard Sale Pizza in Hoxton absolutely exceeded expectations. From the first bite, you could taste the quality of the fresh ingredients — everything tasted authentic, perfectly balanced, and made with real care.
The margarita pizza was the standout for me. The base was beautifully thin and crispy with the perfect crunch, while still staying light and airy inside. The tomato sauce was rich, fresh, and full of flavour, paired perfectly with creamy melted mozzarella and fragrant basil. Chilli oil is a must.
The atmosphere had a cool, laid-back Hoxton vibe, and the staff were friendly, welcoming, and efficient. You can tell this place takes pizza seriously without trying too hard.
If you love proper flavourful pizza with fresh ingredients and a perfectly crispy base, Yard Sale Pizza is a must-visit. Easily one of the best margarita pizzas I’ve had in London, and I’ll definitely be coming back for more.
Easily one of the best pizzas we have ever had. We had the vegan pepperoni and it was insane. The vegan garlic dip was a game changer too, so tasty !! The staff were super nice and friendly. We loved our experience here.
Delicious vegan pies!
Loved that we were able to get crisp crust and some nice bubbles!
Was super impressed with the creative flavors, and the sauces are not lacking! Was surprised they went as far as using real vegan yoghurt for the vegan garlic and herb dip!
Got this pizza delivered to me and it came within 30 minutes. It was tasty and large and still warm! Had to walk about a few meters to grab it from the driver but when I got it, it was worth the meters my hungry butt has to walk!!!!!! See full fully eaten pizza below:
